Pros and Cons of Homeschooling vs. Public School (From a Mom Who’s Experienced Both)
When it comes to your child’s education, one of the biggest questions parents face is: Should we choose homeschooling or public school? Both options come with unique benefits and challenges, and the choice often depends on your child’s learning style, your family’s values, and your lifestyle.
In this post, we’ll take an honest look at the pros and cons of homeschooling vs. public school and share from our own family’s experience navigating both. Whether you’re curious about the flexibility of homeschooling or the structure and resources of public education, this guide will help you weigh the differences so you can make the best decision for your child’s future.
The Pros of Homeschooling
Families decide to homeschool their children for many different reasons. For some, it’s a desire to integrate faith and religious values into daily learning. Others choose homeschooling because of health concerns, special learning needs, or the flexibility it offers military families who move every couple of years. Some parents simply want to take a more active role in their child’s education and feel homeschooling is the best way to do that.
No matter the reason, homeschooling offers unique benefits that appeal to a wide range of families. It provides the opportunity to create a customized learning environment where children can thrive without the pressures or limitations often found in traditional classrooms. From stronger family connections to the ability to learn at a child’s own pace, homeschooling continues to grow as an educational option across the country.
Here are just a few benefits that many families experience when they choose to homeschool:
Personalized Education
Homeschooling allows you to tailor lessons to your child’s learning style, pace, and interests. If your child struggles in math but excels in reading, you can adjust the curriculum to support growth in both areas without pressure to keep up with a class average.
Flexible Schedule
Homeschooling families enjoy flexibility in daily routines, vacations, and learning times. This is ideal for families with unique work schedules, frequent travel, or those who want to integrate faith studies or life skills into their child’s day.
Closer Family Bonds
Spending more time together naturally builds stronger relationships. Many homeschooling families report deeper connections and better communication between parents and children.
Less Exposure to Negative Influences
Parents can protect their children from bullying, peer pressure, and some behavioral issues often found in traditional school environments.
Opportunity for Real-Life Learning
Homeschooling makes it easy to integrate practical life skills, field trips, and hands-on experiences regularly, enriching your child’s understanding of the world.
The Cons of Homeschooling
Homeschooling is not for everyone, or for every family. It takes a tremendous amount of dedication, planning, and commitment from you as the parent. Unlike public school, where teachers, administrators, and staff share the responsibilities. Homeschooling places most of the responsibility directly on your shoulders. It truly becomes a lifestyle, not just an educational choice, and that can be a big adjustment if you’re not used to it.
I’ll be honest, there are days I’ve thought, “If only I could shrink my oldest daughter back down and homeschool her again.” But the truth is, it probably wouldn’t have worked very well for us at the time. Our personalities might have clashed, and we would have butted heads constantly. That’s the reality many families face. Sometimes homeschooling sounds ideal in theory, but in practice, it can be overwhelming.
Before deciding, it’s important to weigh not only the benefits but also the challenges that come with teaching your children at home. Here are some of the most common cons of homeschooling. Things to carefully consider as you think about whether it’s the right path for your family.
Time Commitment
Homeschooling requires significant time and dedication from parents, especially in planning, teaching, and record-keeping. This can be challenging if you work full-time or have multiple children at different grade levels.
Limited Socialization Opportunities
Although homeschooling co-ops and community programs exist, children may have fewer daily opportunities to interact with peers compared to public school settings.
Less Access to Specialized Resources
Public schools often have specialized teachers, advanced labs, sports teams, music programs, and extracurricular activities that may be difficult or costly to replicate at home.
Potential for Parental Burnout
Balancing the roles of parent, teacher, and homemaker can become overwhelming without strong routines, support systems, and breaks built into your schedule.
Ready to explore homeschooling for your family?
Download my free guide “Homeschooling 101: Getting Started with Confidence” to learn how to set up your homeschool, choose the right curriculum, and create a routine that works for your family.
The Pros of Public School
As mentioned earlier, homeschooling is a big commitment for both parents and children. With public school, much of that weight is lifted because there’s already a system in place. Certified teachers, school administrators, and established curriculums ensure that children are following state standards and receiving a well-rounded education without parents needing to design lessons or track progress on their own.
Another major benefit of public schooling is the wide range of extracurricular activities available, often at little to no cost. Sports teams, music programs, theater, art clubs, and after-school activities give kids opportunities to explore their talents, discover new interests, and build friendships. As a former public-school student myself, some of my favorite memories came from these activities. Whether it was performing in choir, playing in the band, or competing on the sports team. Those experiences helped shape who I am and gave me a sense of belonging that I might not have had otherwise.
Of course, not every school district offers the same programs, and access to certain activities can vary. But overall, public schools tend to provide opportunities for students to learn and grow outside of academics in ways that can be difficult to replicate in a homeschool setting.
Here are just a few of the benefits of public school that families often appreciate:
Structured Curriculum & Certified Teachers
Public schools follow a state-approved curriculum taught by certified teachers trained in education methods and classroom management.
Diverse Social Environment
Children interact daily with peers from different backgrounds, learning social skills, teamwork, and conflict resolution in a structured environment.
Access to Extracurriculars and Special Programs
Public schools often provide sports teams, music and arts programs, STEM clubs, advanced placement classes, and special education services that can enrich a child’s educational journey.
Less Parental Time Commitment
Parents can focus on work or household responsibilities without the added task of full-time teaching, while children are engaged in school during the day.
The Cons of Public School
Even though I had the privilege of attending a very small school district and still live in one now, public school does have its challenges. When I say small, I mean really small: my entire high school had around 250 students total from grades 9–12. Because of that, I was blessed to know most of my classmates and teachers personally, and the smaller environment made it easier to feel connected.
But not every family has that experience. Many public schools are large, and with big class sizes, it can be difficult for students to get the individual attention they need. A child who struggles in math or reading can easily slip through the cracks simply because a teacher has 25–30 other students to focus on.
Another challenge I’ve seen is with sports and extracurriculars. In bigger schools, competition is fierce, and there are only so many spots on a team. That often means kids need to specialize and master a sport at a very young age if they want a chance to play in high school. For families who value balance or want their children to try different activities, this pressure can be discouraging.
And then, there’s the values piece. Because faith has been completely removed from the public school system, it can feel difficult to raise children with strong Christian foundations while they spend 7–8 hours a day in an environment that doesn’t reflect those same values. For many families, this is one of the biggest concerns with public education.
These are just a few of the cons I’ve personally seen and experienced. But here are a few additional ones to think about as you weigh your options:
Large Class Sizes
Teachers often manage classrooms with 20-30 students, making it difficult to provide personalized attention to each child.
Limited Flexibility
Public schools operate on strict schedules and attendance requirements, leaving little room for travel, extended family time, or spontaneous learning experiences.
Exposure to Negative Behaviors
Bullying, peer pressure, and exposure to differing family values are potential challenges in public schools.
Standardized Testing Pressure
Many public schools emphasize standardized testing, which can create stress for students and limit creative, exploratory learning opportunities.
My Honest Opinion: Why We Chose What Was Best for Our Family
Before I share our story, I want to make it clear, I have the utmost respect for teachers. This isn’t about them; it’s about the system they’re required to work in.
Even though I was just an “okay” student myself, I received the help I needed early on. At the age of three, I was diagnosed with a learning disability (likely dyslexia), and because of that diagnosis, I qualified for extra support that helped me succeed in school. Unfortunately, I can’t say the same for my daughters.
My oldest attended the same public school I did. She didn’t have the same struggles I faced, but school was still very hard for her. The problem was, she didn’t quite struggle enough to qualify for help. She was one of those kids who slipped through the cracks. For 11 long years, school was a constant battle between her and me, and between us and the school system. It was exhausting and heartbreaking to watch her fight so hard without getting the support she truly needed.
When my youngest daughter started school, I began to see the same problems unfolding again. And honestly, I didn’t have another decade of fighting in me, especially when I knew there could be another option: homeschooling.
You might wonder why I didn’t think of homeschooling earlier with my oldest. The truth is, it wasn’t even on my radar back then. When she was young, I became was a single mom when my husband passed away when she was only six years old. At that time, I didn’t know a single thing about homeschooling, let alone consider it possible for our family.
But life changed when I had my youngest, got remarried, and became a stay-at-home mom, the door to homeschooling opened. We decided to “just try it” for a year to see how it went. I won’t lie, it was intimidating at first and I wasn’t sure how we would manage. But looking back now, I can confidently say it was the best decision for our family. The freedom, the growth, and the peace it has brought us is something I will always be thankful for.
When it comes to the debate of homeschooling vs. public schooling, the truth is there’s no one “right” answer. Both options come with unique strengths and challenges, and every family has to weigh what works best for their situation. For some, public school provides structure, social opportunities, and access to resources that can be life-changing. For others, homeschooling offers the flexibility, personalized learning, and faith-centered environment their children need to thrive.
What matters most is that your decision reflects your family’s values, your child’s learning style, and the environment where they can succeed—not just academically, but emotionally and spiritually as well.
For our family, homeschooling turned out to be the best fit. But your journey may look different, and that’s okay. At the end of the day, you know your child better than anyone else, and you have the ability to make the choice that’s right for them.
So take time to pray, reflect, research, and talk with other parents who have walked both paths. Whether you choose homeschooling, public school, or even a combination of the two, remember: you are your child’s greatest advocate, and the love and support you give them will matter more than anything else.
